Religion makes you a better person?

So Cherie Blair has got herself in trouble again

I always feel a little sorry for Cherie- she has been a tabloid target for years. There is something gawkishly vulnerable about her that always made me sort of like her, whilst being a little afraid of her at the same time.

But I suspect she is no fool.

But this latest story- it seems she was sitting as a judge in the case of a man who had suffered some queue rage, and ended up breaking a man’s jaw.

Inner London Crown Court heard that Miah, 25, of Redbridge, east London, went into a bank in East Ham and became embroiled in a dispute with Mohammed Furcan about who was next in the queue.

Miah – who had just been to a mosque – punched Mr Furcan inside the bank, and again outside the building.

Ms Booth told Miah that violence had to be taken seriously, but said she would suspend his prison sentence because he was a religious person and had not been in trouble before.

She added: “You are a religious man and you know this is not acceptable behaviour.”

The National Secular Society soon latched on to the story with a howl of militant evangelical atheistic outrage, feeling that Cherie’s comments meant that she might have treated a non-religious person less leniently.

I suspect that Cherie’s comments have been taken way out of context, and that if we examined most of the summing up comments made by Court Judges when passing sentence, we would find much more juicy morsels to splash around the red top papers.

But the story seems to have stimulated a wider debate about whether religion really does make people behave better- and whether faith makes us better people. And if so- then are Buddhists better than Followers of Jesus, or are Muslims better Pagans?

What do you think? Because I am not sure.

I can not comment on other faither, but I have known a lot of bad behaviour in churches. But I have also noticed that on the whole, people are motivated to do good. For every insensitive bigot, there are a whole lot of other folk who are seeking to live better lives.

In my experience, society is full of wonderful people, who seek to make the world a better place. Some of them have faith which gives a code for life, and a bridge to understanding things in a deeper way.

However we are all capable of such good and such evil. Sometimes religion brings out both.

I have not used one of these voting things for a while- so here we go-

4 thoughts on “Religion makes you a better person?

  1. I have to agree with the humanists. One would hope a religious person would have a good values system but there is no way you can say that secular person A has better or worse values than religious person B. I agree with your sentiments in you posting. I too have seen behaviour in churches as bad or even worse than in business or the wider world.

    • Hi Steve

      There was some interesting stuff around the <a href="“>Charter for Compassion

      This seems to me to be an attempt to find the common ground across religions, and to harness belief systems for good. People from our background will think this looks a but like universal syncretism, and I suppose critics might also suggest that this has never worked before.

      I think that grace is set loose in the world, and it finds its way into all sorts of situations- even the church. If not especially the church!

  2. I believe there are wonderful people who have values and morals regardless of religious affiliation. When it comes to legal matters religion should not play a role. One person should not be treated differently (whether it be more or less leniently) because of religion. It is quite possible that her words are being taken out of context like you suspect but they can be easily construed as being bias and as such people in those positions should be very careful in those kinds of situations. However, I do belief that the wider debate that has been sparked from this is a quite valid and important one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.